Senate Approves Liability Assistance for Health Care Providers, PPE Manufacturers, Schools, Business and Government Services Providers

HARRISBURG – Health care providers, schools, businesses and others who followed COVID-19 public health directives would be protected from unfair lawsuits for good-faith actions they took during the pandemic under legislation approved by the Senate yesterday, said State Senator Bob Mensch (R-24).

House Bill 1737, as amended in the Senate, aims to head off waves of lawsuits that could bankrupt already struggling employers and unfairly harm institutions who did their best to follow the changing and sometimes conflicting guidance provided by state and federal governments.

People and entities covered by the legislation would still be responsible for any intentionally wrongful acts and acts considered “reckless.” Most will also be responsible for any “gross negligence.” (Manufactures of personal protective equipment who donated PPEs or sold them at cost are protected against “gross negligence” claims.)

Under the legislation, claims of negligence must be demonstrated by “clear and convincing evidence,” rather than “by a preponderance of evidence.”

The measure applies to health care providers, PPE manufacturers, schools, universities and childcare providers, as well as business and government service providers.

The legislation does not provide complete immunity for anyone. It simply ensures that if people or entities follow public health directives established by federal or state governments, they will not be held responsible for any harm that allegedly occurred.

House Bill 1737 also provides liability protection to farmers who want to host agritourism events like hayrides, farm tours and corn mazes. The site must post specific warning signs, and have a signed, written agreement with a participant that they have acknowledged the risk of participating in an agritourism activity.

The amended bill was returned to the House of Representatives for consideration.

For more information on Senator Mensch’s legislation, visit  State updates can also be found on Senator Mensch’s Facebook at or Twitter @SenatorMensch.

CONTACT: Madison Scarfaro  (215) 541-2388